BETWIXT AND BETWEEN
"The way through the world / Is more difficult to find than the way beyond it"
Wallace Stevens
Sometimes people come to therapy with a specific problem they want to work on. Other times there is only an ominous feeling. Perhaps that feeling is the “problem” itself: something we want to get rid of. In the first case the question is, How do I solve or fix this? In the second, How do I make this feeling go away? In both cases, to “solve” a problem usually means to cease the problem being a problem at all.
But it is not clear that certain problems can ever really be solved. And if they are, we may have only found a more convincing way of avoiding or defending against the reality the problem points to.
So if problems cannot always be solved, what can we do with them? And, more importantly, what is the function of psychotherapy?
Change is not what we think it is. We might assume that if a problem were resolved, we would be all ok. A more interesting question might be: What do I get from being in this problem? And what do I give up by “fixing” it? Problems are conflicts that generate tension, and tension is where we know ourselves, where a sense of “I” comes into being. One way of understanding identity is that “I” exist in relationship to particular, essential problems or conflicts.
Therefore, psychotherapy, perhaps is less about fixing problems than identifying core ones – problems that are mythically charged for us. Many ‘problems’ can function as defences, or even as attempted solutions, to more fundamental conflicts. Getting to know our core problems allows us to live intentionally rather than aversively: we find a way through instead of beyond (Wallace Stevens). What changes is not the problem itself, but our relationship to it, and the sense of possibility that opens within it. As Adam Phillips suggests, psychotherapy is less about solving our problems than finding better ways of being in them.